GENEVA, November 9, 2026 — A draft World Health Organization model that could help governments identify packaged foods for possible regulation has drawn criticism from major food and beverage companies, which say the proposal risks shifting attention away from nutritional quality. The draft would consider not only levels of sugar, sodium and certain fats, but also added colours, flavours and sweeteners used to make products more appealing.
The WHO published the draft integrated food-profiling model on November 2 and opened a public consultation that runs through November 27. The document is intended to help governments decide which industrially produced, prepackaged foods should be consumed in moderation and could fall within the scope of measures such as front-of-package warning labels, marketing restrictions, taxes or public-procurement rules.
For the first time, the agency’s model combines nutrient criteria with specified ingredients used primarily for sensory purposes. A product may be identified if it exceeds one or more thresholds for saturated fat, trans fat, sugars or sodium, or if it contains one or more of the listed colours, flavours or sweeteners. WHO says the presence of those ingredients does not mean they are unsafe; they are included as indicators of formulation that may increase a product’s appeal and consumption.
Why the proposal has drawn criticism
The International Food and Beverage Alliance, which represents major multinational food and drink companies, said it was concerned that the approach could divert attention from nutritional quality and undermine reformulation efforts. The group also warned that companies could face higher costs from recipe changes and labelling requirements, as well as possible taxes and litigation.
The industry’s position reflects a wider dispute over how governments should define and regulate ultra-processed foods. Some researchers argue that industrial formulation and additives can be important signals when assessing the healthfulness of a product. Others say broad definitions can group together foods with very different nutritional profiles and may not adequately distinguish products that are high in nutrients of concern from those that are not.
WHO officials say the model is intended to complement, rather than replace, existing nutrient standards. Katrin Engelhardt, a technical officer in the agency’s nutrition and food safety department, told Reuters that food formulation can matter alongside nutrient content when governments design policies to reduce diet-related disease. Researchers quoted by Reuters also said nutrient profiling and approaches that consider processing are not necessarily competing frameworks.
What the model would and would not do
The draft is guidance for governments, not a binding international rule. It does not automatically ban products, require a specific warning label or impose a tax. Countries would decide whether to use the model and how to fit it into their own laws, food systems and public-health priorities. The consultation is intended to gather feedback from governments, researchers, civil society and industry before the document is finalized.
The WHO’s consultation page says the model is designed to identify industrially produced, prepackaged foods that should be consumed in moderation within healthy dietary patterns. It also asks stakeholders to comment on the practicality of applying the criteria, the information available on ingredient lists and nutrition labels, and how the classification system should be used in regulation.
That distinction is important for consumers. The draft does not declare that every product containing a listed colour, flavour or sweetener is harmful. Nor does it establish that a specific brand or food should be taxed or removed from sale. Those decisions would require national policy choices and, in some cases, additional scientific and legal review.
Why U.S. readers should pay attention
Food manufacturers sell products across borders, and international standards can influence how companies design recipes, disclose ingredients and prepare for regulatory changes. U.S. consumers may see the debate reflected in future discussions about food labels, artificial colours, sweeteners and the growing market for ultra-processed products. Companies with global supply chains may also monitor whether different countries adopt similar criteria.
The proposal could become one reference point in the wider debate over how to encourage healthier diets while preserving clear, evidence-based rules. But the outcome remains open. The public consultation closes on November 27, after which WHO says it will review comments before finalizing the model. Until then, the draft should be treated as a proposal for discussion, not a new regulation or a finding that the listed ingredients are inherently unsafe.
Sources and reporting credit
This original report was cross-checked against Reuters, November 9, 2026 and the World Health Organization’s official consultation notice, November 2, 2026.




