SAN FRANCISCO, November 10, 2026 — A federal appeals court has blocked California from enforcing major parts of two landmark corporate climate-disclosure laws, ruling that the state likely went too far in requiring companies to publish climate-risk assessments and emissions tied to suppliers and customers.
The Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals issued its decision on Monday, November 9, in a lawsuit brought by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other business groups. The ruling is a preliminary-injunction decision, not a final judgment declaring the statutes permanently invalid. It sends part of the case back to a federal district judge while leaving some reporting obligations in place.
The dispute concerns two laws signed by Gov. Gavin Newsom in 2023. Senate Bill 261 requires companies doing business in California with more than $500 million in annual revenue to publish reports on climate-related financial risks. Senate Bill 253 applies to companies with more than $1 billion in revenue and requires annual greenhouse-gas emissions reporting.
Which reporting requirements remain
The appeals court allowed California to continue enforcing SB 253 requirements covering Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions. Scope 1 refers to greenhouse gases from sources a company directly owns or controls, such as fuel burned at its facilities. Scope 2 covers emissions associated with purchased electricity, heating or cooling.
The panel blocked enforcement of the law’s Scope 3 reporting requirement for now. Scope 3 covers indirect emissions across a company’s value chain, including suppliers, transportation, employee commuting and the use of products by customers. The court said those disclosures were less directly connected to a company’s own operations and commercial transactions.
The court also reversed the denial of a preliminary injunction against SB 261 in its entirety. It reasoned that climate-risk reporting requires companies to make predictive and sometimes subjective judgments about future economic conditions. The majority concluded that the state had not shown the requirements were narrowly tailored enough to survive the applicable First Amendment review. The court returned the question of whether the Scope 3 provision can be separated from the rest of SB 253 to the district court.
Why the legal reasoning matters
The case turns on the constitutional limits of compelled speech. California argued that investors need consistent information about emissions and climate-related financial exposure to make informed decisions. Business groups said the laws force companies to make contested assessments and create costly compliance obligations.
The panel treated direct and purchased-energy emissions data differently from supply-chain estimates and climate-risk forecasts. It found that the first two categories were factual disclosures closely tied to companies’ own activities, while the other requirements raised broader questions about how businesses must characterize risks and third-party conduct.
One judge partially concurred and partially dissented, arguing that both statutes should be blocked at this stage. That separate opinion underscores that the court did not speak with one voice on every part of the constitutional analysis.
What it means for businesses and investors
Large companies with California operations still need to monitor the reporting requirements that remain in effect, especially direct emissions and emissions from purchased energy. Businesses should not assume the entire California climate-reporting framework has disappeared. The status of Scope 3 disclosures may depend on further proceedings, including the district court’s decision on severability and any additional appeals.
For investors, the ruling may reduce the amount of standardized climate information that some companies must publish under California law. Companies may continue to disclose such information voluntarily or under other legal and market requirements, so the decision does not eliminate all climate reporting.
For U.S. readers, the case could influence how far states can go in requiring companies to disclose information about environmental risks. It also illustrates the tension between transparency for investors and constitutional limits on government-mandated corporate speech.
Sources and reporting credit
This original report was checked against the Ninth Circuit’s November 9, 2026 opinion in U.S. Chamber of Commerce v. Sanchez, Reuters coverage of the ruling, and a legal analysis of the decision.





