JUNEAU, Alaska, November 11, 2026 — An Alaska judge is weighing whether Democrat Mary Peltola’s campaign can obtain records identifying absentee ballots rejected during the state’s unresolved U.S. Senate race, a dispute that puts voter privacy and election transparency in focus while counting continues.
Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews heard arguments on November 10 and said he expected to issue a written decision quickly. Peltola’s campaign is seeking lists of absentee voters whose ballots were rejected and the reasons for those decisions. The campaign says it wants to ensure that eligible votes are counted and that the review process can be monitored. It has said it has not seen evidence that the ongoing review is being mishandled.
Why the campaign wants the records
The lawsuit was filed after the November 3 ranked-choice election, in which Peltola is challenging Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan. The race remains too close to call as absentee, early in-person and other ballots are reviewed. Peltola’s campaign argues that the requested information is a public record and that it would help identify whether ballots are being rejected for valid reasons.
Campaign observers are already allowed to watch absentee review boards at regional election offices. But the reports available to observers are limited and must be handled under confidentiality agreements. Peltola’s lawyers say a centralized record would allow the campaign to monitor the process more effectively without disrupting election workers or ballot counting.
The state’s privacy argument
State attorneys oppose releasing the records, saying the daily reports contain confidential information, including home addresses, and are temporary working documents that can change as reviews continue. An election official told the court that the state’s voter database cannot produce a version of the report that removes all protected addresses. The state also argued that campaigns should not receive information before voters themselves can check their ballot status.
Election officials said no absentee ballot is finally rejected until the state review board completes its process and results are certified. Campaign observers may view limited reports under confidentiality agreements, but they cannot keep, copy or record them. The state says voters can check ballot status online only after certification, and the information is not posted until at least 10 days later.
Alaska’s system also has a limitation that could matter to voters: the state does not provide a process for voters to correct some common absentee ballot errors, such as a missing signature on an envelope. That makes accurate review and clear notice important, particularly when a close race is still being counted.
What happens to the Senate race
Alaska accepts ballots from overseas voters for up to 15 days after the general election, making November 18 the final day to receive those ballots. The Division of Elections has scheduled additional vote counts this week and expects to conduct ranked-choice tabulations around November 18 if no candidate receives more than half of the first-choice votes. The final outcome will depend on the ballots that remain eligible and the state’s counting procedures.
Sullivan’s campaign filed in support of the state’s position, but said that if the judge orders disclosure, the same information should be made available to all candidates at the same time. That request reflects a concern about fairness between campaigns rather than a claim that the ballot review itself is invalid.
Why it matters to U.S. readers
The case highlights a recurring challenge in close elections: campaigns seek enough information to verify that votes are treated properly, while election officials must protect private voter information and keep the count orderly. Public access rules differ by state, and the balance between transparency and privacy can become especially contentious when a race is undecided.
As of the latest court report, the judge had not issued a ruling. The lawsuit does not establish that ballots were improperly rejected, and the state’s privacy arguments have not been accepted or rejected by the court. The next development will be the written decision and the continued counting of ballots before certification.
Sources and reporting credit
This original report was prepared from the following reporting and primary materials:





